ImaginaryManticore said: "QueenAlice said: "Perhaps it was just my experience as a woman watching it, but I felt like the boyfriends came off like a good performance at “Broadway Backwards.” Tons of fun,but not at all believable in regards to what is realistic in relationship to male love interests for a female protagonist. If George Firth were still alive he would undoubtedly have done some significant revamping to the book. Are there any other women on this board who saw the production? I’m really curious what you all thought."
Replying to this a few days late, but. The first time I saw this production, I kept noticing the reversals and had a similar reaction to the boyfriends. Fun to watch but I kept thinking of how they were originally written. But there were new, unexpected angles that I found believable, especially a surprisingly sinister turn to 'You Could Drive a Person Crazy'. And I went back to see the show a few more times and by the end I wasn't thinking about it; the boyfriends were the characters. I think the whiplash could be resolved by a few small staging tweaks and a different actor for PJ, who was by far the weakest.
I convinced several friends to see it who had no familiarity with Company (or Sondheim) and not a single one of them thought about the gender flipwhile watching. They all loved the showand responded as if it had been originally written that way."
I took people to the theatre and not only did they not think of the gender switch they actually had an amazing time (they are not theatre fans). It’s basically the only production of a Sondheim musical I could now unequivocally recommend the general public to see without worrying about the reaction. People are starting to hear about the Jake G Sunday and are asking me about it. Some have even dove in and bought tickets. They don’t know what they are getting into. Company is a big load of well crafted intelligent fun with accessible themes and an entertaining score. Thinking about its chance of success in NYC, I think it has the best chance for good word of mouth of any recent Sondheim revival I can think of (and I’ve seen all of the recent ones).
Give me claws and a hunch, just away from this bunch.