Saw this tonight via standing room - they didn't have a rush today. The standing was in the mezz which offered an awesome view.
I didn't see Mueller which I'm bummed about, but I actually really enjoyed the show. I thought Kennedy was great. She made no impression on me in JCS, but I thought she was great tonight. Her accent wasn't overwhelming or weird to me at all. The girl from Heathers was great. As soon as she came on, I thought she sounded like one of the Heathers, read her bio, and was like oh yeah. Spector really wowed, I thought. His lines were great, his singing was gorgeous. The guy who played her boyfriend...not so much. I don't know if it's just the role or what, but the acting felt very surface, and the singing felt very forced.
The set was really gorgeous. I loved all the layers and whatnot. I thought the book was pretty great, but I thought the show finally kicked in after Carole's big speech about how she's going to do it on her own! The audience clapped, and that felt like when the show should have kicked in, but instead it was near the end. I was more interested in Carole going out on her own, etc. But that seemed to not be the focus.
Also, weird side note: But the first scene where Carole meets Geof where they're in college, and their is randomly a piano in the hallway? Huh? Weird. But still I thought it was pretty successful show.