I fully agree with HeyHerMusic's issues with the updating. As a boomer, I can attest that no one in our generation would sing "The Ladies as Lunch," even with the changes. I saw the OBC (well, Russell replaced Stritch) when I was 19, and knew that Joanne was my mother's generation. There's simply no way a boomer woman of Manhattan -- where I lived 24 years, adjacent 45 -- would sing "clutching a copy of Time, just to keep in touch," and that's just for starters (no one clutches a copy of anything, unless it's to swat a buzzing insect). It's an analog lyric in a digital age and though nitpicky points up how ludicrous it is to assume that words can be slipped into another demographic. Joanne trades on being observant and savvy, pithy and accurate, and the lyrics reflect the worldview of a woman born in 1925, not 1951. The entire prism on Manhattan women is without contemporaneity, the breath of 2021 reality. I just feel we ride the good intentions of the update without really stopping to accept the disconnect. Joanne today would have weathered Vietnam, gone to college, had a career, not languished on the Upper East Side with nothing to do but lunch. If she's just Larry's wife, why is she friends with this young woman Bobbi? The show, pre second wave feminism, reflects a view of married women in the generation prior to ours. You can argue til you're red faced, but Joannne is not a boomer, certainly not in Manhattan. And the ladies, if they lunched, would be all over cell phones, without clutching.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling
Updated On: 11/20/21 at 10:17 PM