Posted: 6/26/17 at 1:09am
greenifyme2 said: "broadwaybaby2123 said: "I just wanted to post here and say that I saw Colton Ryan perform as Evan in today's matinee and thought he did a PHENOMENAL job. It was my third time seeing the show and I took my dad, who was really looking forward to seeing Ben Platt perform. When we heard the news that he would be out, we were both disappointed but couldn't switch our tickets so we decided to make the best of it. I LOVE Ben and think he's insanely talented, not to mention PERFECT for the part, but I will say that seeing it with Colton as Evan in no way changed how great the show was. Not once did I wish that Ben was playing the part instead -- I was too wrapped up in enjoying Colton's performance.
Just wanted to put this out there for anybody reading this thread who is nervous about Ben being absent when they see the show, or is considering selling/exchanging their tickets to see him. Yes, it's disappointing to learn that the big-name lead is going to be out, but in this case it really didn't matter. I highly recommend giving Colton a shot if you have the opportunity to! I couldn't be happier that I did, plus it was so interesting as a DEH fan to observe some of the little nuanced details that Ben and Colton did differently. Bottom line: they are both incredibly talented performers and they will both give beautiful performances!
"
Would love to hear about a few things about their different takes on the role if you have time!
"
If you have specific questions, PM me! In general, they were both surprisingly similar -- I sort of thought that I'd be seeing two really different versions of 'Evan Hansen' and that wasn't the case, Colton does a really good job at replicating the things Ben is known for being great at (things like posture, tics, word inflections). Colton did add some new tics that Ben doesn't do, and I noticed that his take on Evan's voice is less fast-paced and more of a stutter (but not in an overdone way). Both are great singers, I was very very happy with Colton's voice and thought he hit every note perfectly. Colton flubbed his lines twice but in super minor ways so it didn't matter at all. Those are the biggest things I can think of, but let me know if you have more specific questions. Overall both are impressive performers and I am happy to report that Colton does the role great justice!