Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026 — Page 4

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#76

GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

Did I suggest it would be a good or bad thing? No. I was simply describing a reality.

But thanks again for the type of profound responses that validate decisions to spend less and less time contributing, something people seem to increasingly be doing judging by a cursory review of the board.

#78

GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

Robbie2 said: "Jordan Catalano said: "After almost 15 years away from Broadway, I don’t care what the tagline is, I’m stoked for Raul’s return."

Hopefully, Raul's last musical Leap of Faith was such a black hole. We couldn't wait to escape the St. James!
"



I actually loved "Leap of Faith". Saw it twice and am actually drinking my coffee out of the mug from the show as I type! JMO


Just give the world Love. - S. Wonder
#79

GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

Dolly80 said: "This won’t be round for long."

This board often wonders why Buena Vista Social Club is extremely successful like it doesn't occur to people that there are Spanish speaking people all over the world that come to/live in New York. This board is a not a good indication of the average tourist but somehow is always wanting/complaining about new works. I think a lot more people will be interested in this that you might think.


wck.org

Updated On: 5/23/26 at 03:12 PM

#81

GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

Every time I see that "He gave us stars" tagline, I think of Kenneth Parcell on 30 Rock. "'Believe in the stars.' It's like that doesn't even mean anything anymore!"

#82

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

Some of these ticket prices are insane for a first preview $231.00
Well I didn't want to get into it, but he's a Satanist. Every full moon he sacrifices 4 puppies to the Dark Lord and smears their blood on his paino. This should help you understand the score for Wicked a little bit more. Tazber's: Reply to Is Stephen Schwartz a Practicing Christian
#83

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

When Schmigadoon announced for Broadway, there was a whole thread of people saying how hard it was going to flop and how any producer would be insane to put their money in this. No one on this board knows anything.

#84

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

Rentaholic2 said: "When Schmigadoon announced for Broadway, there was a whole thread of people saying how hard it was going to flop and how any producer would be insane to put their money in this. No one on this board knows anything."

Schmigadoon has a TV following that kept it afloat in previews. New musicals without major fan bases are typically not surviving. Let’s hope this doesn’t flop, but there currently is no “buzz.”

#85

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

Ensemble1698878795 said: "Rentaholic2 said: "When Schmigadoon announced for Broadway, there was a whole thread of people saying how hard it was going to flop and how any producer would be insane to put their money in this. No one on this board knows anything."

Schmigadoon has a TV following that kept it afloat in previews. New musicals without major fan bases are typically not surviving. Let’s hope this doesn’t flop, but there currently is no “buzz.”


"

No buzz because it doesn’t even start previews for months…

#86

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

RippedMan said: "Ensemble1698878795 said: "Rentaholic2 said: "When Schmigadoon announced for Broadway, there was a whole thread of people saying how hard it was going to flop and how any producer would be insane to put their money in this. No one on this board knows anything."

Schmigadoon has a TV following that kept it afloat in previews. New musicals without major fan bases are typically not surviving. Let’s hope this doesn’t flop, but there currently is no “buzz.”


"

No buzz because it doesn’t even start previews for months…
"

Buzz has nothing to do with when the show starts. It has to due with the excited anticipation of audiences and fans. Example: The Spring Awakening revival or Paddington. This title and names behind it don't incite excitement. Again, that's not to say the show won't be good. It just means the show is a hill ahead of it to earn its audience.

#87

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026


Buzz has nothing to do with when the show starts. It has to due with the excited anticipation of audiences and fans. Example: The Spring Awakening revival or Paddington. This title and names behind it don't incite excitement. Again, that's not to say the show won't be good. It just means the show is a hill ahead of it to earn its audience.

Exactly. The Lost Boys started marketing their show 7 months before it even started. The buzz and excitement for that show was huge and it's doing really well, which is no surprise. Most shows have to do that if they want it to be successful. People are excited and talking about both of the shows you mentioned because their marketing departments know exactly what they're doing. This show starts in less than 4 months and no one is talking about it, not even here. Raul is wonderful but is not a huge star, so they need to figure it out. A lot of people are fascinated with Galileo Galilei, but why should they go to this show?


wck.org
#89

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

They need to get with the zeitgeist. Rebrand as "Heated Galileo." Add some nude shower scenes. Cast Jesse Metcalf as the "telescope."


...
#90

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

Sutton Ross said: "
Buzz has nothing to do with when the show starts. It has to due with the excited anticipation of audiences and fans. Example: The Spring Awakening revival or Paddington. This title and names behind it don't incite excitement. Again, that's not to say the show won't be good. It just means the show is a hill ahead of it to earn its audience.

Exactly. The Lost Boys started marketing their show 7 months before it even started. The buzz and excitement for that show was huge and it's doing really well, which is no surprise. Mostshows have to do that if they want it to be successful. People are excited andtalking about both of the shows you mentioned because their marketing departments know exactly what they're doing. This show starts in less than 4 months and no one is talking about it, not even here. Raul is wonderful but is not a huge star, so they need to figure it out. A lot of people are fascinated with Galileo Galilei, but why should they go to this show?
"

Is Lost Boys really doing that well??

#92

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

So, showing us the same clip posted 2 days ago doesn't mean it's generating buzz. It got positive notices at Berkeley (Just like Almost Famous) but that clearly doesn't mean much when it comes here. I look forward to how they are going to generate excitement for this production and I hope they've improved the score.


wck.org

Updated On: 7/22/26 at 12:06 PM

#93

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

The California reviews were mixed leaning away from commercially promising. I read 'em all because I have close friends who (via a family member) are very much production adjacent; they all flew out. No one believed the reviews promised Broadway at the time, but clearly a belief in this show is significant enough to pull it East and into the Shubert. I wish it well, but I'm fascinated that it is coming without another tryout.


"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling
#94

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

The capitalization is $23 million dollars as of the last SEC filing, so I doubt they'd want to spend another 4-5 on another tryout and add to that number. Apparently they did another lab/workshop since Berkeley. Did anyone see it?

#97

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

To points raised in my earlier post, and my friends' dismay; Variety (May 17, 2024) nails the general consensus in Berkeley, which prompted my post::

"It’s hard to imagine an easy road ahead for a show whose theme is fairly rarefied by musical-theater standards, yet whose sometimes hokey, simplistic tenor is unlikely to generate the critical support needed to lure in more mainstream audiences ...

"That duo' {the designers'} stimulating array of religious, scientific and celestial imagery is arguably the show’s best element, as well as the only one that conveys the ideas at hand without jokey or sentimental pandering.

"Otherwise, book and lyrics alike are often ham-fisted, whether going for snippy quips or trying to make us feel emotional depths these cardboard characters can’t approach. The central relationships are off: A stereotypically feisty, ahead-of-her-time Virginia swerves between urging her father to defend science and the opposite, their parent-child bond failing to convince as a result..."

"Showstopping moments are in service to songs that feel like throwbacks to the MOR radio rock of forty years ago or more—artificially inflated, grandiose incitements to Bic-lighting. They’ve got some notably clumsy lyrical hooks, like the young lovers’ insistence that their hearts beat “Louder, Louder,” or the ensemble’s repeated chanting of the word 'faith.'

"The conception of Galileo himself as Renaissance cock-rocker, endlessly pleased with himself might’ve worked in the hands of a performer and show more humorously self-aware. But Esparza’s committed turn doesn’t lend that narcissism much saving irony. And despite scattered one-liners, “Galileo” at present feels all too sincere in treating a celebrated historical standoff as the kind of slick, shallow, glorified concert that would make better sense if performed by the likes of Meat Loaf and Bonnie Tyler."

A year later, are we once again in Danny Strong trouble? An open question. Maybe a workshop fixed it, as opined above; yet the issue raised by Variety sound organic to the concept, and that's why I scratched my head and wondered where the $20 million came from.



"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling

Updated On: 7/22/26 at 06:11 PM

#99

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

I mean how can all the people who were force-fed the hype that Danny Strong had at long last fixed the book of CHESS, be terribly excited about another DS musical book so soon after that debacle?


Sister George
#100

Re: GALILEO to Open at the Shubert Theatre, Fall 2026

I don't trust my own recollections, so I looked up my thoughts on the Berkeley Rep version of the musical in May 2024:

Galileo is a frustrating show - worth seeing for the performances, set and lighting design, and a second act that has a genuinely interesting confrontation between the title character and his longtime ally, who is now the pope, along with more variety than the first. It's easy enough to grasp, almost too easy, with a score that is too repetitive (especially in the first act) and lyrics that don't move the story forward at all - except a couple of times in the second act.

I didn't dislike the show, and my wife enjoyed it more than I did, but there was something a little too predictable about it - with one notable exception. The cast is first-rate, with Raul Esparza playing the scientist as an arrogant but gifted rock star. That's fun for a while, especially because the book - as written by Danny Strong - also makes clear that he is as devout as the leaders of the Catholic Church who are suspicious of his ideas and rebellious nature. I had never seen Esparza live before, much less from the second row, and he was in good voice during the fifth performance of the weekend Sunday night.

Madalynn Mathews plays Galileo's daughter, Virginia, who is unmarriageable because her father is not financially independent and is also considered a scandalous figure. This leaves her in a nunnery by the second act. She makes the most of a tricky role that's constrained by her character's limitations. The most intriguing performer on stage is Jeremy Kushnier, a Broadway veteran who plays Bishop Maffeo Barberini. He is so inspired by Galileo that he writes a poem (well, fine, it's a song that he performs while shyly looking away from Esparza's character) about him and is his biggest supporter within the church hierarchy, which is very afraid that Galileo's insistence that the earth revolves around the sun will challenge the prevailing dogma in a way that will turn Catholics into Protestants. Strong deserves credit for making this concern seem less ridiculous than it sounds. The dynamic between Esparza's Galileo and Kushnier's Barberini is always interesting, and Kushnier - given the largest variety of songs along with high energy, a charming sense of humor and a lovely falsetto - practically steals the show. The opening song of the second act is a hilarious showstopper that also illustrates how becoming the pope is changing the former bishop.

The new pope has other problems - he's an embattled military leader against Protestant armies in Germany - and he gives a careful blessing to another attempt by Galileo to promote his theory. But Galileo pushes his luck, and his old friend - influenced by his enemies in the church, including cardinals played by Javier Munoz (of Hamilton fame) and Bradley Dean, as well as military leaders - feels betrayed. This leads to the best scene in the show, a showdown between the Pope and Galileo in which both men feel wronged but only one has power.

The score by Michael Weiner and Zoe Sarnak isn't bad, exactly. But as others have noted, the songs do tend to blur together, and the lyrics fall into an unfortunate habit of repeating words over and over. In fairness, things improve in the second act. But the show, directed by Michael Mayer, peters out with some predictable uplift.

I liked Galileo more than many of the professional critics, but it's easy to enjoy a new musical with strong, Broadway-caliber performances and some innovative effects. I assume this is just the first stop and another out-of-town tryout is coming. But despite the talent involved, I'm not sure the show can be fixed for Broadway just by banning the lyric writer from using the words "faith" and "louder." But I agree with Kitsune that Galileo, flaws and all, is worth checking out.

-----
I don't know what changes have been made since then, aside from Joy Woods in the role as Galileo's daughter. It's a thankless role unless it's been revamped. The reviews then were decidedly mixed, and the Variety review was a mocking pan. It captures many of the things that I didn't like about the show but felt too harsh. There's some good stuff in the show, along with imaginative lighting work, and I admired the way Strong treated his characters as serious people with real beliefs, instead of as cartoonish 1980s rockers winking at the audience the entire time. The latter approach, which I gather Strong fell into with his adaptation of Chess (which I didn't see), would have been a disaster.

Updated On: 7/23/26 at 02:46 AM

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $83
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67