I'm fascinated by the producing angle, in darkest 2026: Who saw the apparently conceptually flawed show in California and anticipated a return on the dollar - twenty million of 'em - in a commercial venue? I'm reminded of the West End musicals of the 1980s. I remember seeing a weekday matinee Mutiny! with its large mechanical ship, male pulchritude, and instantly forgettable score. David Essex and Frank Findlay were the stars, and the show lumbered along soliciting applause from a set that moved like Norma's house but little else*. This show, with its intellectualism lite prism on history - a dialectic between secularism and faith-based restrictions on science - feels like a throwback to the pre-Les Miz days when a new La Mancha was sought: a colorful character and an era heretofore unexplored in musical theater that could find contemporaneity in theme (how timely; Hello Home Sweet, Homer, with Yul Brynner.)
If Esparza is reason to see it, then he'll have to stick with it for years. Did the early fold of Chess not teach new lessons? And I'm reaching beyond Strong's lapses: finding bankable stars who can belt til the roof shatters isn't easy. I remember how shocked many were than neither Menzel nor Chenoweth could pull an audience when their vehicles weren't adored. Maybe this will be the exception, and I, too, will be there (likely on TDF) to hear Esparza. But whoever is producing this has more faith than the Pope portrayed in the story.
*Update, it played 500 performances, but was based on a semi-successful concept album, i.e., a cousin of Evita and Chess. 500 performances sounds impressive, if not profitable; but it never survived long enough for recasts..
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling
Updated On: 7/23/26 at 04:36 PM