Babe_Williams said: "Also, I really like Welcome Home from Bandstand."
I saw this thread and thought, "Oh Welcome Home from Banstand!" Yes it is a great song. I love the whole musical honestly and wish it was still on. It had its flaws but the dancing was amazing.
the entirety of Pirate Queen. "With You" and "Suspend my Disbelief/I Had a Life" from Ghost. And although it has yet to close, (and I don't necessarily view it as a total flop) Head Over Heels has some pretty great material, especially Alexandra Socha's take on "Good Girl" and "Here You Are"
Two that haven't been named that I really loved: "Show Some Respect" from The Last Ship--such a great group number. And perhaps a controversial choice as I know a lot of people thought it should've been cut: I adored "Playing Nancy" from Groundhog Day.
And to repeat one, I think the song I love the most from a show I disliked the most was "Fly, Fly Away" from Catch Me If You Can. I know some loved it. It was very much not my taste. But in the midst of the whole thing, that song just devastated me. Truly magical.
The 2001 revival of "42nd Street" didn't recoup - even though it ran for not quite 4 years, and won a few Tonys. The entire score from that show, is filled with great songs.