I'm new here, but got great advice, and wanted to report on my experience yesterday. I work at 50th street, and decided to line up on a Wednesday after work. Yesterday's weather was cold, so I hoped that would improve my chances. I got to the line at around 5:05. Ahead of me was a guy who was there around 2pm, when I went over at lunch to scout the line. After that was a group of maybe 4-6 people who had been there since 2:30, a couple and a father/daughter who got there around 4, and another young woman who got there a few minutes before I did. There were no line sitters! Around 5:45, the first guy got tickets, then the 2:30 group got tickets a little after 6. At 7:10, the couple and father/daughter got tickets. The young woman and I only wanted one each, there was a pair of friends behind us who joined around 5:30, and then additional people, at least 10 who joined the line after 6.
Since I was second at 7:10, and had read about the woman who got a ticket at 8:02 a few posts above, I stayed positive, and sure enough, four of us got tickets at 8, and I ended up in Orchestra Row G on the aisle! The last eight of us were all sitting together in row F & G. The tickets cost $177, and they were fantastic seats! It was a little weird to sit down, and try to turn off my phone and take off my coat as the lights were dimming, but If you are at the front of the line after 7:15, you still have a chance! I think the weather helped me, and also the fact that people who lined up in the morning had gotten into the matinee, nobody stayed for the evening performance. I brought some hot food in a thermos, and that really perked me up around 6:30. I also dressed warmly. Have a plan for dinner! The young woman in front of me had to buy expensive pretzels in the theater at intermission since she hadn't had anything to eat. I'm going to try again with my daughter when she's home from college, she can line up earlier on a Wednesday. Thanks for all the good advice posted here!