Phillypinto - I suppose 'Hand To God' makes more sense as it's come from an Off-Broadway well attended run and got very good reviews. It's also does not base it's worth on a 'star', and has rather good advertising.
Meanwhile, 'Living on Love', does depend on the draw of it's 'star', a 'star' who's really only incredibly well known in the opera world, which has steadily declined over the past decade.
So yes, Hand to God makes much more sense. Jeez, why do you constantly have to refuse to see what's right in front of you?