It seems to me it was a bad idea, since its catharsis and resolution are about a not terribly exciting court decision. Though Santa invites magic, it just doesn't sing, despite the Macy's setting (in a way, "Big," a far better show, had the same problem: "She Loves Me" aside, retail isn't a great milieu for song and dance). I recently watched the not terrible remake of the film, and the story just grinds along, everyone pretty and decked out in pricey duds. It's odd, it's about rich people in NYC who have the blues about ... being rich people in Manhattan So the big emotional moment is about a little girl living in a 5.5 million co-op getting a 3 million bucks home. Not exactly "Annie" or "Oliver." It pretends to be middle-class, but uh-uh. It's curiously unmoving.
Isn't it funny? Willson could've been ideal for "A Christmas Story," the midwest, the era, even the plot had his name all over it.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling
Updated On: 12/13/15 at 07:50 PM