Posted: 3/20/19 at 1:49am
JayElle said: "Good to know Sweetlips. I thought the producer selected the cast. He seems to get his fingers into everything."
That's true in theory, but the theory only occasionally governs who gets the ultimate say. You might enjoy the chapter entitled "The Muscle" in William Goldman's essential book on Broadway in the mid-20th century, THE SEASON. (A couple of the chapters are out-of-date because the book was written before ticketing became computerized, for example; but most of it is still relevant fifty years after publication.)
The Muscle, as Goldman uses the term, is the party with the best track record and/or most forceful personality among the creative team. To paraphrase Goldman, The Muscle might be the star if the star is Ethel Merman or Mary Martin--UNLESS the director is Jerome Robbins (GYPSY) or Gower Champion (I DO! I DO!). The Muscle was definitely the producer if s/he was David Merrick (again, unless Champion was directing) or Hal Prince.
Goldman then goes on to caution us about productions where The Muscle is the costumer or the lyricist. His point was to object to critics who write something like "Joshua Logan forces Mary Martin into the most unflattering postures", saying one can be sure Miss Martin did nothing she did not bloody want to do. (This is NOT his example; I'm just making it up because I had eye surgery today; I'm fine, but I can't go reread the chapter at the moment.)
Updated On: 3/20/19 at 01:49 AM