Figured this would be a good thread to bump for what I have to say.
So I saw Jersey Boys once before, but John was out and Dominic Nolfi was on...who I mean, wasn't bad or anything...
But from all I've been hearing about JLY, I was very anxious to see him, and finally did so tonight.
He seemed to be having a teeny teeny bit of understandable vocal problems, as just the highest notes sounded a bit raspy. But everything else he sang amazingly, I mean even those notes were great.
But from everything I was expecting...he is a great singer, there's no denying that...but I was more impressed by his acting than singing!
He had the character down from the start, and you believed he was aging without any physical changes...he just kept changing his voice, so...I almost didn't notice he wasn't physically changing if that makes sense...the sound of the voice was enough to convince me that the character had aged.
The major dramatic moments though...you know some...he was pretty heartbreaking in. I teared up a bit. Little moments too he was very moved, and he lashed out great. Just...wow.
Cerveris gives a fantastic performance, no doubt, but considering how great JLY's singing is, and the fact that IMO his acting surpasses his singing...I think he deserves the Tony.
Ooh, and I did like the show better this time. There was understandably much more chemistry, and all the other actors are wonderful, like last time.
I still am in the minority who thinks TCP was the best (sometimes I wonder if I saw a different show than most people...), but tonight I decided JB deserves the Tony over DC.
"If there was a Mount Rushmore for Broadway scores, "West Side Story" would be front and center. It snaps, it crackles it pops! It surges with a roar, its energy and sheer life undiminished by the years" - NYPost reviewer Elisabeth Vincentelli