"I thought her voice was beautiful in real life"
I agree. When i saw her in New York i thought she was excellent. Her acting was superb and she had a lovely voice, though clearly not as strong, clear, and controlled as Kelli's.
And even being a HUGE Kelli O'Hara fan, i came away really really liking Katie's performance. The only part i was too disappointed on was "Clara's Interlude"
However on the Live at LC broadcast, it just wasn't too good.
I do hope she gets another chance, she's vary talented and just needs some more time to grow and get better and better.
"...and in a bed."