I was also there last night, all the way in Row E of the Balcony. After sleeping on it, here are some thoughts:
In my mind, Taye has the potential to be one of the best Hedwigs to ever set on stage. But let me emphasize the word potential, because last night was a huge example of how much work he has to still do to get to that point.
The most obvious highlight of this incarnation of the show, like many have said, is the soulful quality of his singing/the songs, making them almost sound brand new. Particularly his Wicked Little Town and Origin of Love were among my favorites. Taye also has this beautiful aura of confidence (in some aspects) of the role that are truly a joy to watch, particularly when he speaks his new lines of dialog, my favorite being references to his career and an awesome joke about the Jeffersons.
As many have also mentioned, he is also the saddest of Hedwig's, and I can't wait to see him evolve those aspects of his role as his run continues. It was so touching, especially when he is playing Hansel's mother and saying her lines before Angry Inch.
As for things to work on, I actually was a bit disappointed with his approach to Tommy. Maybe it's because I was so surprised and shocked by Darren's version, that this was automatically gonna be a let down, but I'd like to see him try and differiate that character more as he continues.
I hope that the make up/wardrobe department helps him figure out the sweating/make up issue, since (especially during the car/Wig in a Box malfunction) that was definitely getting in the way of his performance.
Overall, I will definitely be returning to the Belasco to see his evolution as Hedwig in about a month or so, and already have tickets to see him near the end of his run in Oct. He definitely is a candidate for being in my top 3 favorites, if he keeps working at it! Go Taye, go!