I knew of TC from the films CAPOTE and INFAMOUS, but before seeing those films I had no idea what that line meant.
Okay so about the songs with the gypsies...
I'm sure Megan Sikoura was thrilling as Bonnie as many have said. I just don't get the point of those characters. As Ray said, they don't make sense. You never really see them other than at the bar and do nothing to advance the plot. I think they're only there to make it more '70s. The only reason I would keep "Applause" is because it's the title song...but even that being in the bar has no significance.
I'm sure most of you have seen the movie "All About Eve" which is so incredibly perfect. The idea to musicalize it sounds amazing but the complete product that was produced almost 40 years ago does not even compare.
There is no mention of chorus people in the film (I can't remember, is Margo in a straight play in the musical as she is in the film?), it's just Eve wanting to be a star - she's the only one with ambition, which makes you feel for her to begin with. With all the gypsies in the musical, though, it's like, "Oh, well they want to be stars too...so you're not all that special. Why is Margo taking you under her wing?" All of the gypsies in the bar stem from Eve herself. I'll explain:
Instead of the horrible song "Fasten Your Seatbelts", Margo just said the classic line in the film - a line which the song ruins. Further, Eve, sort of in a trance, delivers a wonderful speech about what it means to hear applause:
"Eve: Imagine... to know, every night,
that different hundreds of people
love you... They smile, their eyes
shine - you've pleased them, they
want you, you belong. Anything's
worth that."
That line is what the whole song "Applause" is based on. It should really be her song, and it should be sung at the party while Margo is having her drunk tantrum instead of the awful "Seatbelts" song. Instead they added a whole other plot element with the gypsies, taking up a whopping two scenes and having nothing to do with any of the main characters. From what I heard Erin Davie didn't give all that steller of a performance, so if there ever was a revival or a re-tooled version (probably not any time soon because of the flop I've heard Encores was), maybe Megan Sikoura could replace her as Eve and get more of a chance to shine.
I wish I could make my own version of the musical based more on the original screenplay - including the few good songs from the seventies version - and adding other better ones. However, since I am only 16 and nobody would listen to my ideas, someone else has to got to make a better musical out of the wonderful film. Or it should just be a straight play - left alone - in its perfection. I mean my gosh - that "Good Friends" piece of nothing replaces Margo's amazing speech about working at being a woman..."That's one thing all women have in common, being a woman. Eventually we've all got to work at it." How could it get any better than that? It can't. And Bette Davis? Good Lord...
Sorry for the long rant, but that's just how I feel. The movie is one of the best ever made, and the musical is just...not. You might all think I'm totally wrong. Who knows?
You look absolutely terrific, honestly.