Agreed, Caroline. TUTS has produced an exciting piece of theatre since at least 2002 (that's as far back as I remember off the top of my head).
The tour of Les Mis was just in Houston about three years ago. Rent was just here last year, and it's coming back for another weekend this season.
I have no reason to pay the money to see a TUTS show. The tours are usually okay quality, but they're never exciting pieces of theatre (this year Color Purple, Legally Blonde, Rent), and the TUTS produced shows are underwhelming and disappointing. The cast members they bring in from New York are usually miscast (the one notable exception being Max von Essen as Tony in West Side Story, but even he couldn't save that show).
Other Houston companies are producing good-quality shows for less, like Masquerade (Parade, Chess, Lucky Stiff, Jane Eyre), Stages (Grey Gardens, Baby, Spitfire Grill), and Main Street (Light in the Piazza and Caroline or Change). Theatre Lab has of late been doing new, less well-known musicals (Bright Lights Big City and Nursery School Musical).
My grandmother loves TUTS. She likes to go see musicals there and she loves them, no matter what. She loves all the flashy sets and costumes and high-energy dance numbers. I took her to see Parade at Masquerade- she said it was boring because there wasn't any "dancing or shiny costumes or high-kicking showgirls." She thought Legally Blonde was a lot of fun.
TUTS has its audience; I choose not to be part of it.
"I believe that art does not exist only to entertain, but also to challenge one to think, to provoke, even to disturb, to engage in a constant search for the truth."
- Barbra Streisand