Posted: 11/2/17 at 9:50am
Great hearing all the different reviews of this one. I was in DC the passed weekend and decided to see this....
Big fan of Tina Fey and I do think Mean Girls is a funny satire, but I just didn't get this at all. For me, this just isn't a musical. And I'm not sure Fey, her Husband/Composer Jeff Richard, and lyricist Nell Benjamin made a compelling argument that it is one. The characters just didn't seem to have real reasons to sing. And sticking to the movie so closely didn't help. And by the end, I'm not sure the point of the show was very clear.
People are praising the book, but although I find some of Fey's jokes funny, they seem like a grab bag full of random party favors that don't add up to a well crafted stage story. Yes, the audience was eating it up, but new musicals based on popular movies typically do attract excited fans in tryouts like this....the Saturday Matinee crowd that that makes things like Hamilton a hit will, I'm predicting, not be that excited to see this.
The girl clique musical is just not that interesting on stage as it is in movies, maybe its because the forms are so different. They tried it with Jawbreaker...which i think is a much better musical idea, no one bought it. Even Lawrence O'Keefe who wrote the Heathers Muscial (a much more tuneful, teen inspired, cool score) is on record as saying Broadway audiences don't care about these stories much. Tina Fey's name can only carry this so far.
If the score is usually the star of the show the way it is with Wicked, Hamilton, Dear Evan Hanson....this one doesn't shine that bright. It feels pastiche, like someone said this is what Broadway is supposed to sound like. It doesn't feel like the music is telling a teen story, the orchestrations aren't telling us anything about the world we are watching. And the lyrics don't help. I was trying to remember hooks the way I did when I first saw Hairspray (a really quality teen centric musical), I could remember almost all of the hooks in that show after one time seeing it...Benjamin hasn't found the words that really make this characters memorable on stage the way they were in the film.
I just didn't connect to these characters like I did with the film ones. There's not much heart here in my opinion. I hate to say this, but I think this could be the flop of the season. Just my opinion. Not purposely trying to be a pessimist here. Not sure that Tina Fey's joke writing can save this one. I certainly wouldn't recommend this to people for 70-150 dollars a piece.