Maybethistime - Mistoffeles doesn't disappear into thin air in the stage production of CATS - that was clearly something they digitally did for the movie version.
I can't believe people listed DEFYING GRAVITY as the most impressive special effect...it's the cheapest, worst effect I've ever seen on the professional stage and completely ruins what would otherwise be a great moment in the show. Anyway...
Some of these aren't very amazing "special effects," but more just really amazing things i've seen happen on stage.
1.) The fountain in BOMBAY DREAMS. Yes, I'm well aware that the show was bad, but that scene is undeniably fantastic. The choreographed water spouting out is amazing and 10x better than the London production. If every scene in BOMBAY DREAMS produced the amount of excitement that single song did, the show would be around for a bit longer.
2.) The stage filling with water during "The Grand Canal" in NINE, and then slowly draining as Contini's world is falling apart. Amazingly touching and beautiful to listen to.
3.) Almost every single god damn thing about DANCE OF THE VAMPIRES. If that show had only stuck around long enough for more people to see it, it would have swept the Tonys in the design categories. It was absolutely technically brilliant. I got chills during every scene change.
4.) During TITANIC when the entire stage tilted and everything slid to one side as the boat was sinking. Now even this show has it's rampant haters (which completely baffles me,) even they can't deny that it's pretty amazing to see an entire broadway stage lift and tilt with actors sliding across it as if they were falling off the boat.
5.) Cathy Rigby's flying choreography in PETER PAN. I was in a production of THE WIZARD OF OZ. It was right after DANCE OF THE VAMPIRES had closed, and we got all their flying equipment. All out harnesses were still labled with the DOTV actor's names on them so we had top of the line equipment with first rate "flyers" showing us exactly what we could do with the actors in the air. After seeing how much work it took to get an actress to take off on stage on a bicycle across stage, I can't imagine how long it must have taken them to master Cathy Rigby's flying in PETER PAN. I was in PETER PAN as well and the flying was not easy, so when I saw her production, what she did in the air really blew me away.
As much as I would love to say the chandelier falling in phantom, I can't. It doesn't even fall. It slowly and carefully glides to the stage, unharmed. If you ask me, it's really crappy and very lame.
I know there's more...
"If you are going to do something, do it well. And leave something witchy."
-Charlie Manson