GeorgeandDot said: "I don't think it's fair to suggest that Benanti isn't a professional, especially considering that her absences were due to a broken neck and a secret, unexpected pregnancy. I would argue those are two pretty good reasons to call out of a show. I don't recall her missing many performances of Gypsy and Women on the Verge. Ambrose is missing from this production simply because she's not equipped to perform the show 8 times a week. It's not like she's doing Evita. If they really felt sure that they wanted to cast someone without much musical theatre experience, they should've trained her months in advance to make sure that her voice was in the strongest, healthiest shape to perform the role in."
You probably weren't around BWW from 2000-2008 ish , but it was bad regarding Benanti's treatment. People didn't know her health history (just like we don't know Ambrose's reasons for going down to 7 shows) but people really took her to task for her absences during Into the Woods, The Wedding Singer, etc. Like I said in my original post, it was not until Gypsy and her opening up about her health issues that caused her to miss so many performances and to leave shows early that people changed their tune. I like to think it taught some people a lesson in assuming things about performers. The critiques she was receiving was so bad that Benanti even did an interview where she castigated the entire Broadway online community (calling it chatlines) and saying they are ruining Broadway with their negativity and talking smack about performers who work so hard and put so much craft and workmanship into that these negative people online have no idea about.
In other words, from a certain time period on BWW, not many would have bet hard money that Benanti would have been able to handle She Loves Me 8 shows a week.
Updated On: 7/6/18 at 04:42 PM