I did see the original on Broadway, and Jill O'Hara is exactly as (our) Michael Bennett says: she was special for that time...and right for that part. She sounded like she was going to fall apart at any moment, a terribly vulnerable and dependent young woman in a hopeless relationship with an older, married man. Things have changed A LOT since then! Are audiences today really going to accept, understand and sympathize with a woman like this??? This is the age of "empowered women"! Elphaba, Violet, The Edie Beales!!!
I agree that this casting seems bizarre, but I will give Kristen Chenoweth this: her dramatic scenes in THE APPLE TREE were really touching (even though she was playing a fully "empowered" woman.)
Besty is so right about the original cast being made up of "actors" and MB is so right about the ensemble being made up of "dancers"...especially Donna McKechnie. She was just breathtaking in "Turkey Lurkey Time." The audience was mad for her!
I'm not a fan of Neil Simon's, but a huge fan of Burt Bacharach's. I just don't know if this show is do-able anymore. I remember getting the CD a few years back and being so excited to hear it again (and of course knew every lyric even though it had been decades since I'd heard the album). Yet it really struck me as being horribly sexist, which was
de rigeur at the time, I realize, but those doling out the sexism tended to be nothing like SEAN HAYES!
I love the thought of Snagglepuss in Chinese pajamas though. I'd pay $136.50 in a heartbeat to see that.
"Be on your guard! Jerks on the loose!"
http://www.roches.com/television/ss83kod.html
**********
"If any relationship involves a flow chart, get out of it...FAST!"
~ Best12Bars