Random, I think you are putting the cart before the horse.
My theory is this, replace Sutton with Tari and Tari will become the star people will want to see. The reason will be that people like me, who have seen her, will make it happen. The press will also make it happen. Talent will win out, find its champions, and keep a show, especially one as wonderful as Marshall's production of Anything Goes - which many have said is even better with Kelly than with Foster - going as far as it can.
A purpose of casting is to make stars, not just to recycle - whoops, perhaps "reshuffle" would be the better term - them.
Also, with due respect to Ms. Scott or Ms. Block, who might also do quite well in the role, they are not necessarily going to sell tickets on the basis of brand recognition either. If you want to go that route, get Jane Krakowski (who btw would probably be great).
Tari Kelly is a star waiting to happen. (Just like Sutton Foster was before Millie). I am sure there are some people who have seen Tari's Reno who would say I am overstating her star power. But I would venture to say they would be few and far between and wouldn't know talent if it woke them up in the night with a sledgehammer.
If Broadway is concerned about nurturing it's top talent, then it has to do just that. And she's the top!
Updated On: 10/16/11 at 11:29 AM