The Other One said: ""Anyway, on the topic of Denzel, I love him, he can do no wrong. But even though I’d certainly be interested in him playing this role, and I imagine they would dress him up to downplay his features and physique, I feel like he’s too perfect looking to be Willy, a complete loser whose appearance is the subject of mockery."
I don't know about that. Denzel easily slips into the manner and appearance of the working class man. He did so in Fences, he did so in The Taking of Pelham One-Two-Three; he is better at it than any other star I can think of offhand, frankly. It's in his roots, which he has always been true to.
"
Troy’s a very different role from Willie. They’re both washed out losers, but totally different kinds. Troy’s alluring, charismatic, and attractive in a way that Willie isn’t. Denzel playing Troy doesn’t mean he’s right for Willie.