AlexWesthof said: "Jarethan said: "SweetLips22 said: "The back stage gossip from this disaster will almost be as juicy as the previous Sunset at the Regent Theater.
Ms Brightman will never set foot on the Opera House stage unless in one of her candy floss away with the faries heavily mimed gloss and smoke fantasies.
Everything about her puts my teeth on edge.
Yes. I feel better now."
i agree with you. I just don't get the love for Brightman. Isaw her first in London in December 1986 and twice in NYC in early 1988).I still think she is the worst Christine Daae I have seen.
On that first trip, I also managed to see Claire Moore (first) in a matinee in Dec 1986 (just lucky timing...we had a post-Christmas week in London scheduled.I remember also paying scalpers to see a second performance 9with Brightman)...I am virtually positive that scalpedseats in the Dress Circle cost me 55pounds (gone are the days). Claire Moore set the bar so high that Brightman seemed awful by comparison. When /i have seen her on TV (PBS), her vibrato made me leave the room. Oh, well, no accounting for taste."
I've seen both Sarah Brightman and Claire Moore as Christine when I lived a few streets away from Her Majesty's. Sarah was NOTawful in comparison. She was always pitch perfect.I always feel like this is a myth in the theatre community: rooting for the underdog who wasn't married to the composer etc - aka: Jealousy. Don't get me wrong, Claire Moore is an amazing performer, but I thought she was a bit too mature as Christine. Even though she could hit every single note, her voice didn't have the innocence/puritylike Sarah's. But Claire really is extremely versatile. She'sthe bestEllen in Miss Saigon I've ever seen (a mezzo role that wouldn't fit Sarah). I feel like her voice blossomedmore in her lower register than soprano."
I think my problem with Brightman in Phantom was that she was very wooden. I agree that she sang those songs very well 38 years ago, but she still had no charisma, at least to me. I don't now if CM ever began successful in England or not, but I really did think she had a chance, because her stage presence was so strong, in addition to her acting and beautiful singing. I just never warmed up to Brightman.