123musicalfan said: "Ensemble1716440075 said: "I wonder who in the world had the idea of asking her...she was never known for her acting abilities, and her voice doesn't match others who have done this role. Her personality does reflect Norma in some ways, with how she is the perpetual ingenue.
I've seen people describe her as taking the role in another direction, being verydelicate/fragile...sorry, but I think that's baloney. It's her default setting."
My belief is that the reason she was asked to do it (and why she accepted) is because of her association with ALW. She has appeared in the original London cast of two of his longest running musicals (Cats and POTO, which is still running), the original Broadway production of POTO (longest running Broadway musical so far), was in Aspects on both sides, Requiem, Song and Dance, did multiple Music of ALW tours all over the world (including Australasia with Anthony Warlow), recorded multiple albums of ALW's music over the years (including one titled 'Surrender' of all things), has appeared in many concerts of his music, and in addition, was not only married to him, but has been called his 'muse' and 'Angel of music', and he has been vocal about the fact that she was the inspiration behind his longest running and best known musical.
It's not surprising that producers of the show would have thought it a brilliant idea to cast her. Leave aside her personal success as a (non theatre) performer with her albums/concerts/other endeavours, the sheer magic of her connection with ALW would have been a very enticing prospect.
As far as she is concerned, I'm sure she discussed with ALW who would have been thrilled and would have decided to go ahead. I know she enraged some peoplewhen she said the score was written for her, but I feel what she meant was that ALW wrote a lot of the music while they were married, and that she would have tried them out.With One Look, as ALW said, was written for her, around her voice for the Little mermaid, As Is If We Never Said Goodbye I think was written for Cricket initially, which would have been while they were married. She was also (i believe) the first torecorded things like Surrender, Too Much in Love to care, The Perfect Year in her albums.
To be fair to to Sarah, she hadn't shown a lot of interest in returning to musical theatre. She said in an interview in1999 (this was before one of her big tours) that she hadn't bought any cast recordings for a couple of years, because she was listening to a different type of music and her life was going another way. In a Graham Norton radio interview a few years ago that her favourite musicalsare theold school Rodgers and Hammerstein shows, and that the extent of her theatre-going is to watch therevivals at the Kennedy Center, in addition to a few other shows.
So it was probably a very excited director/producer that decided to cast her in it. I can see that ALW would have been thrilled (there is no noise from hims however, probably busy with Starlight Express ... I always felt he might go for the opening on Sydney if the production goes ahead) at the prospect of his muse singing his music again.
"
I think this is a very lovely post. I've no affection for Brightman (nor antagonism), but I love your post. The one thing I would disagree with--and you aren't the first to say this--but I don't get any impression that Lloyd Webber was thrilled with her playing the part. Because he's been stone-cold silent the entire time and didn't show up for the opening. I'm not saying his against the casting or has any issue with Brightman. Just that the impression it gives me is that he's fairly indifferent about the whole thing.