I was there tonight to and really enjoyed it. The Encores benefit was fun, but this is on a whole different level.
Jake IS George. His voice is rich and full of light. Truly, it's the best performance I've ever seen him give, stage or screen. Ben Platt may be winning the Tony this year, but in my mind there will always be an asterisk by it because he didn't beat Jake. Those damn dogs are so hard to pull off and Jake walks away with that scene like it's child's play. One of my favorite parts of Daniel Evans' performance was the way he delivered the final line...so many possibilities...and then that look of wonder overtook his face like the biggest light bulb went off. Jake takes his time with the line, pondering over each syllable of "possibilities" (you've got possibilities and how, Mr. Gyllenhaal!) and his final look gave me chills.
Ashford has grown has grown quite a bit scene the benefit; her Marie is slightly stronger than her Dot, but another strong performance that compliments Jake's work. You really feel like their acting partnership only makes the other stronger.
The rest of the cast is a parade of stars and they each do well with their bits. Ashley Park is very funny and this is the most impressed I've been with Erin Davie on stage. Philip Boykin's two characters are so wildly different that when he first starts speaking at the gallery you almost think it's a different actor.
I've always considered Sunday in the Park my second favorite musical/score behind The Most Happy Fella, but each time I see the show it inches a little closer to overtaking Loesser's work in my heart. I know some people try to malign the second act, but I find it even stronger, and certainly more emotional, than the first. The return to Paris through the end has to be one of the finest 20 minutes of book and score ever written for the musical theater.
Chromolume #7 is almost too dazzlingly in this production. I know George is supposed to be repeating himself and the work has gone a bit stale, but unless the six Chromolumes before it were the exact same thing, count me as impressed by his talent. Maybe some real life artist should create George's seven Chromolumes and display them in the Guggenheim or something.
It's funny that right next door is a Menagerie revival that is leaving many of us here asking why bring that play back so soon after the gorgeous Tiffany revival. It felt, to me at least, unnecessary and immensely unfulfilling. And yet here we have a revival coming on the heels of the successful Roundabout/Chocolate Factory production, but this revisiting of Sondheim and Lapine's masterpiece feels vital and needed.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!