LuPita2 said: "It's a gorgeous song, just on its own. I remember taking a road trip with two of my non theater loving friends, and they both asked me to play itagain because they both thought it was beautiful When I saw it live, sweet Drew had a very dry throat or something caught in it, so he had to keep clearing it the entire song, I felt terrible for him. I look forward to hearing Jeremy sing it live because it's probably much better in person."
Poor Drew! I find the entire YMTM scene to be really moving in Waitress, and YMTM is also such a gorgeous song also, that it’s a really lovely moment in the show. I think it really works if the Jenna and Dr P have good chemistry. I’ve not seen Shoshana and Jeremy together on stage so can’t speak for that. My fave version is currently Kat McPhee and David Hunter in the West End, because they have a really great chemistry together and you just really feel that their characters need and care for each other, and their voices mesh really well together also <3