Saw the show again tonight. First time since the first preview. I didn’t notice any major changes, but the pacing is MUCH better. I’ve accepted act 2 for what it is, and I enjoyed it much more this time.
Act 1 is honestly close to perfection. Sure it’s not Sondheim’s greatest, but it has his stamp all over it, and it’s a magical blend of book and score throughout the entire first act.
I did hear some Passion this time, particularly in the wonderful “End of the World” duet with Diamond and Jin Ha.
I do think his music is better than his lyrics in this score. But I love how fun and zippy the score is, especially after Assassins, Passion, and Road Show. When is the last time he had written an unadulterated classic musical theater comedy number like the “I’m a Terrible Priest” song?
I continue to be extremely impressed by Ives’ book. It’s funny, witty, modern, and of course very strange. I still can’t believe we have a Sondheim show with 2023 characters. The Company revival is set in the present time, but in HWA, it feels more natural.
Also, I saw Jane Krakowski in the audience and it made me realize she’d be a perfect Marianne, although I wouldn’t trade Rachel Bay Jones performance for anything, she is the heart and soul of the show.
I am very curious what the critics are going to make of this show. The production is so polished that I could definitely see life beyond The Shed.