Understudy Joined: 7/29/07
"Anything But Lonely" - Ann Crumb (Aspects of Love)
"Why" - Raul Esparza (Tick Tick Boom)
"Gethsemane" - Steve Balasmo (JCS)
"Dance of the Robe" - Heather Headley (AIDA)
"Meadowlark" - Patti LuPone (Baker's Wife)
Stand-by Joined: 3/15/09
I'm a grade A sucker for huge chorus numbers featuring rich harmonies and high notes!
-"Make Our Garden Grow": Candide
-"Circle of Life": The Lion King
-"The Flesh Failures": HAIR
-"Make Up Your Mind/Catch Me I'm Falling": Next to Normal
-"The I Love You Song": The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
To name a few. :]
The I Love You Song- Spelling Bee
No One is Alone- Into the Woods
That is, these give me chills when I don't get misty-eyed by them.
Too many songs to list all of them! But...
What I Did For Love
I'm Wishing/One Song, from On The Record
Someone Like You, In His Eyes, A New Life form Jekyll and Hyde
Blue Skies, from White Christmas (Brian d'Arcy James' ending is PHENOMENAL!)
The ENTIRE Light In The Piazza and South Pacific Score
A lot of Little Women
Who I'd Be & Build A Wall, from Shrek
Lippa's The Wild Party
Swing Joined: 8/2/09
Wheels of a Dream- Ragtime
If I Loved You- Carousel
You'll Never Walk Alone- Carousel
A Way Back to Then- [title of show]
Who Will Love me as I am?- Sideshow
I only remember one song giving my chills constantly, which was the end of "My Friends" on the 2000 concert CD with George Hearn, the "AT LAST MY.." followed by the Ballad Reprise directly after was pretty thrilling I think
But since I've listened to that so many times now (well 102 according to iTunes, not sure what is considered 'many' here), I don't get the same effect anymore at all.
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/28/05
This is gonna sound weird, but the first time I ever got real, live chills in a theatre was during Chitty when Raul sang "Hushabye Mountain."
Also:
Say It Somehow - Piazza
Sheer Perfection - King David
Funny - City Of Angels
The Money Tree - The Act
Astonishing - Little Women
Be On Your Own - Nine
The entire OBCR of Parade
Meadowlark (The Baker's Wife)
Defying Gravity (Wicked)
Sunday (Sunday In The Park with George)
Electricity (Billy Elliot)
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/12/04
Till we reach that day -- RAGTIME
Something wonderful -- THE KING AND I (esp. Marilyn Horne's version on Julie Andrews/Ben Kingsley recording)
The Phantom of the opera -- TPOTO
Rebecca (Act II rep.) -- REBECCA
Hilf mir durch die nacht -- REBECCA
Lots of the ones already mentioned have that affect on me, especially This is the Hour from Miss Saigon and a few song in Les Miserables.
The Act 1 finale and The Asylum in Woman in White are pretty emotionally charged and moving, especially seeing them performed live. No Matter What from Whistle Down the Wind (NOT the Boyzone version!!!) has a huge affect on me and is a very moving piece with the innocence of youth and the anger and fear of the adults playing off each other and elements of earlier songs incorporated from both sides.
Off the top of my head:
Overture from Gypsy
You Have To Be Taught from South Pacific
Losing My Mind from Follies
On My Own from Les Miserables
One from A Chorus Line
Quintet (Tonight) from West Side Story
As Long As He Needs Me from Oliver
One I forgot to mention before was "He Lives In You (Reprise)" especially when performed by Phindile McKize.
Not to mention, "Endless Night" by Jason Raize. What a shame he's gone. His rendition of that song is so beautiful and hopeful that it really is hard to comprehend the way his life ended. A really tragedy.
YES! I completely forgot about both of those Lion King songs. Chills ahoy... He Lives In You Reprise is one of my favorite musical theatre songs, especially when Simba comes in on the descant.
"If done right ... and please no stupid comments,
Defying Gravity"
I concur. I saw the show in Seattle a couple of weeks ago and that damn song is still stuck in my head!
Donna Vivino is a GODDESS.
Oh and may I add
"The Light in the Piazza" and "The Beauty Is" - Kelli O'Hara brings tears to my eyes every time.
"Dear Friend" from She Loves Me
"Who's That Woman" from Follies
wickedfan, I definitely agree with "Love Can't Happen".
The overtures for "Gypsy" and "South Pacific" really get me. So does "In Buddy's Eyes".
Living in the Shadows from Victor Victoria, sung by Julie Andrews.
I'm not going to mock anybody for getting chills from "Defying Gravity." It's not the greatest show ever, but the music swell right before "So if you care to find me" IS stunning. I'm glad they didn't put the stupid "It's meeeeeeee" on the cast recording, so you can hear the orchestrations.
I know it's kind of an obvious choice but I remember seeing the original production of "A Chorus Line" when I was little and really got choked up with the original "What I Did For Love." That song still gets me.
There's a World from N2N
Being Alive- Raul Esparza-Company
We Do Not Belong Together- OBC (NOT revival)-SITPWG
Meadowlark-Alice Ripley-The Baker's Wife
Say it Somehow- OBC- Piazza
Touch Me- OBC-Spring Awakening
Perfect for You-OBC-N2N
Children and Art- Bernadette- SITPWG
Breathe- OBC- In the Heights
Make Up Your Mind/Catch Me I'm Falling- OBC- N2N
Plus Maggie's part of At the Ballet... when she repeats At the Ballet 3 times, the third one (the belted E or F I think) gets me every time, especially the one in the movie (only part of the movie I like better than the show).
Videos