I saw it last night and generally liked it. Donna was the clear standout for me, and "Last Midnight" was so awesome. They should just let her do a one woman cabaret act on that set in her green dress. She was so beautiful and enchanting. Another superb performance out of her.
The other really strong performance was from Sarah Stiles. I like the new direction she took Little Red. Jessie Mueller has a lovely, lovely voice, but I found her acting a little on the bland side. It didn't help that her costumes were hideous and I couldn't help thinking how much I hated them when she was on stage.
I know people have been disappointed with O'Hare, but I didn't mind him. I thought his acting was excellent actually, but his singing was what left a little to be desired. I agree with someone above that he had little chemistry with Adams. She herself was fine, and "Moments in the Woods" was her best, well, moment, but she didn't command the stage like I thought she might.
I liked the child narrator spin for the most part. It's nice to see a different take, whether or not it's 100% successful.
There was one aspect I really hated though: the costumes. Other than Donna's I thought they were all different shades of awful and ugly. The set was so lush and pretty and the costumes were a real eye sore. I mean that boy couldn't even dream up a pretty dress for Cinderella? Red didn't even have a cape (it is a cape as red as blood, not a jacket as red as blood). The Step-Mother and Sisters looked like Effie Trinket knock-offs, and the princes could have been Cinna. If it does transfer I'd love to this creative aspect reworked.
Otherwise it was great to hear this score and book again that I so dearly love. Like many here I grew up obsessed with the OBCR and my VHS copy of the taping. I wanted to be Joanna Gleason SO badly, ha! I would practice saying things like, "I need your shoes," and "I pulled it from a maiden in a tower" all time.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!