So, here's what I got from the audio so far. I'm planning on seeing this when it reaches Broadway. Is it a masterpiece? Absolutely not. Does it deserve Broadway? Eh. But, this show is very very charming and likable. However, you do need to be a fan of the show or do your research to get what is going on.
The musical is so much like the TV show. The book adds Patchy the Pirate, karate, the French Narrator, the dolphin swearing censor etc. It also nails the character personalities, style, and humor. It does seem like a Spongebob special screenplay more than than a book of the musical. Like someone said, the book is like a binder of ideas and they're seeing what sticks to the wall and that's not bad for a pre-Broadway run. They have fixing to do. Patchy the Pirate needs to be reduced. I think he should stay because again, you have to watch the show to get it. But, he does overstay his welcome just a tiny bit with the beginning of Act 2. The Patrick cult needs to go. It goes no where and it is not developed at all. Spongebob and Patrick’s relationship needs to be strongly developed, along with the character of Mr. Krabs, I think the musical should focus on the concert for the musical theatre aspect and the volcano for a real plot service.
The music is mostly very good. “Bikini Bottom Day,” “BFF”, “A Simple Sponge,” “No Control”, “Chop to the Top”, and “I’m Not a Loser” are the highlights. I love that “Best Day Ever” was included. I'm super happy that the theme song was include in the bows. “Daddy Knows Best” is a hilarious song that nails Mr. Krabs, but the actor who’s Mr. Krabs and especially the actress who’s Pearl make it. “Tomorrow Is” is a bit dramatic and doesn’t fit in. Patchy’s song at the top of Act 2 needs to be cut or shorten to be just him. The godawful Plankton rap, Patchy’s Song, the Patrick as the Savior song, and Bikini Bottom Boogie need to go.
The acting sounds fine for the most part. I need to really watch the show to judge. Some of the actors did lose their voices sometimes and they need to be careful. A few standouts in a good way and a bad way: Lili Cooper is very cute as Sandy and has a great Texas accent. It sounds like she has the stamina for her. The actress who is Pearl is 100% spot-on with the character and she has an amazing, powerful voice. The weak links from what I’m getting are the actors who are Plankton and Mr. Krabs. Nick loses his Plankton voice for the majority of the show. It sounds like he is trying to channel Plankton with an evil accent, but it’s not enough. The guy who’s Mr. Krabs sounds a bit young for the character and needs a better impression of the character. However, the star here is Gavin Lee as Squidward, whom I think could be a very strong Tony contender, depending on the season. He has a strong presence. He sounds absolutely hilarious and nails the personality, wit, and sarcasm of Squidward. His song and his performance are absolutely fantastic and I can’t wait to see the tap dance. He needs to work on the voice. Sometimes, it’s spot-on like his laugh. Sometimes, it’s serviceable. Sometimes, he loses it altogether. Other than that, Lee is absolutely perfect.
The SpongeBob Musical is off to a pretty good start, but they need a lot of work to do before hitting the Great White Way. I can’t wait to see it up close to see how the direction, movement, and costumes are like. That way, I can judge the show completely. In the meantime, it is better than I thought, but I do like what I’m hearing.
Updated On: 6/11/16 at 09:07 AM