I have been to probably more than 100 shows in the last 10 years and every single one has been the result of rushing for tickets. It was the only way I would have been able to afford to see every hot show that opened on Broadway. But besides the price, it was also about the experience of getting in line early and sitting there for a couple of hours chatting with other theater fans - hot, cold, rain, snow....you name it, I've sat in it on the cold sidewalk. TOTALLY WORTH IT. Personally, I pray that regular rush policies return - in person.
Lotteries, on the other hand, are a different story. I prefer the in-person lotteries because obviously your chances are better when 200 people (ok 1000 for Hamilton) show up in person, rather than the thousands that can enter the online lottery. That is my personal preference, but I can't complain because I have won both in-person and digital lotteries in the past. Like most of you here, I am just grateful and ecstatic that Broadway is finally coming back, so I will be there no matter what. :)