Tony Awards Predictions (All Categories) — Page 4

Jasmine could be a spoiler winner if the Tony nominators really go for Boop. It's more likely that the nomination will be the prize for her because Sunset Boulevard and Gypsy both seemed to have stronger responses.

If Jasmine beat both Audra and Nicole it would be one of the biggest upsets I’ve ever seen. I personally don’t see it happening. 

FANtomFollies said: "The nominations are out.https://www.timeout.com/newyork/theater/the-2025-tony-nominations"

Those are not the nominations, they are Time Out NY’s personal picks.

binau said: "If Jasmine beat both Audra and Nicole it would be one of the biggest upsets I’ve ever seen. I personally don’t see it happening."

I agree. I think people are probably imagining a parallel with Joaquina Kalukunga in Paradise Square sweeping in at the last minute. The difference is none of those nominees really came from rapturously reviewed shows and the presumed front runner's show, Caroline or Change with Sharon D Clarke, had already closed. 

We all have our favorites and who we want to win. It's a wonderful place to be when there are so many strong potential winners in so many categories. I'm personally rooting for Helen J Shen, but I'll be thrilled if she gets nominated with how crowded the category is.

FANtomFollies said: "The nominations are out.https://www.timeout.com/newyork/theater/the-2025-tony-nominations"

I understand these are personal picks, but choosing DBH and Just in time for Best Book of Musical over Operation Mincemeat is demented. I understand the hatred towards the UK transplant which is objectively better that most of the new US musicals this year, but excluding it from the Book nomination looks really personal.

gibsons2 said: "FANtomFollies said: "The nominations are out.https://www.timeout.com/newyork/theater/the-2025-tony-nominations"

I understand these are personal picks, but choosing DBH and Just in time for Best Book of Musical over Operation Mincemeat is demented. I understand the hatred towards the UK transplant which is objectively better that most of the new US musicals this year, but excluding it from the Book nomination looks really personal."

This just tells us that you don't know the meaning of the word "objectively."

gibsons2 said: "FANtomFollies said: "The nominations are out.https://www.timeout.com/newyork/theater/the-2025-tony-nominations"

I understand these are personal picks, but choosing DBH and Just in time for Best Book of Musical over Operation Mincemeat is demented. I understand the hatred towards the UK transplant which is objectively better that most of the new US musicals this year, but excluding it from the Book nomination looks really personal."

Objectively better? Why are you the final say?

MezzA101 said: "2025 Tony Awards Predictions: Kieran Culkin Eyes Historic Triple Crown, Latinos Take Center Stage and Star Power Could Rule Broadway Honors

https://variety.com/lists/2025-tony-awards-nominations-predictions/"

Some very logical and believable predictions, but the increasing indications that Hilty may be left out are depressing.

 

DanS3 said: "I wonder why most predictions are leaving Just In Time out of Best Musical? It got rave reviews. I wonder if it will surprise everyone. But what would it knock out of the top 5 slots?"

It’s a crowded year and the perception- not incorrectly- is that it’s the Groff show, so honoring him can be seen as honoring the show. 

I don't think Deadline's were posted.

Tony Awards Nominations Predictions 2025: Will Hollywood Rule The Day?

https://deadline.com/2025/04/tony-award-nominations-predictions-1236379808/

MemorableUserName said: "I don't think Deadline's were posted.

Tony Awards Nominations Predictions 2025: Will Hollywood Rule The Day?

https://deadline.com/2025/04/tony-award-nominations-predictions-1236379808/"

Greg Evans is not particularly good at predicting aside very obvious choices. He seems a little disconnected from the industry.

vfd88 said: "Does anyone know if Smash is eligible for Original Score? I've seen people say it isn't for obvious reasons, but I've also seen it listed as a contender by some reputable sources. The Tony committee didn't announce any ruling on its score, unless I missed it."

It is not.