I'll repeat the comment of some posters above to say that we are huge fans of Isaac Powell after loving him in ONCE ON THIS ISLAND, but man, does Jordan Dobson do a phenomenal job as Tony until Isaac comes back in the show. No-one should avoid the next month of performances while Jordan is in the role. He's thrilling onstage as an actor, dancer and especially as a singer scaling the heights of the Bernstein score with ease. And frankly he's as beautiful to look at as Isaac. (Am I forbidden from saying that?)
As for the show itself, it's pretty close to a winner in our books, despite our misgivings with past Van Hove stagings. This production creates a new stageplay/video hybrid that for the most part works gangbusters with the material. The translation to contemporary times is thoughtful and legit. The dance movement is kinetic and tells a clear story, if not nearly as varied and nuanced as the Robbins original. The show really knows what it's doing: the music-making, the racial casting (the Jets here are the NATIVE-born gang containing black and white members), the feeling of being in a dream/nightmare you can't wake up from, even the RAIN, are all thrilling choices executed with topnotch talent.
What were my disappointments? I have three. The set is a defiantly bare stage backed by a stage-wide jumbotron. (Really an HD movie screen, but still.) There are some spectacularly detailed sets 30' upstage of Doc's Store and Anita's sweatshop (along with a red bedroom seen only in video) but why oh why couldn't they winch those rooms downstage so we all could appreciate the filmic realism there. Just baffling.
I'm sorry but I love these characters so much that I really want to live with them for a full 2 1/2 hours, not the hour and 3/4 or so that we're given. We landed on the final scene simply too soon to care as much as the full length show would have given us.
And finally, those extreme closeups projected on the jumbotron during songs make those moments absolutely thrilling and visceral. And that's a real problem. Why? Because as soon as Tony or Maria walks OUT of their closeup to move downstage and continue singing, the thrill is gone. It just can't compete with the moments when their faces are projected 30' high. The movie making before your eyes is at war with the live stage show and I gotta say, for the most part the movie wins.
Updated On: 1/2/20 at 08:25 PM