I mean I love the song lyrics to "Tonight" and "Maria" from WSS, but if you analyze them a little closer and forget about the lovely music, as much as I think it is truly one of the best musicals, even THAT, alas, is a combination of good lyric writing and dumb lyric writing.
"The most beautiful sound I ever heard, Maria": Well, maybe. You'd almost make a case if you were talking about the Virgin Mary.
"All the beautiful sounds of the world in a single word...": WHAT?! NO!! That word would be "OM", not Maria.
Of course, there's "Tonight". You think we're safe now that we get to a really poignant, important part in the show. NOT A CHANCE!!!
"Only you, you're the only thing I see forever": SHE'S AS DUMB AS HE IS!!! It's even MORE confused because in real life, no one would really EVER fall in love like Tony and Maria did.
"In my eyes and my world and in everything I do. Nothing else but you, ever.": THAT'S EVEN WORSE!!!! Real love doesn't weaken a person's mind; it's supposed to add a precious seeing to the eye! It's like you're doing your normal errands for the day, and then BOOM, you're doing it for her?! I mean, COME ON!! That would never happen in real life!
"Every sight that I see is Maria": SEE AN OPTOMETRIST, WHY DON'TCHA?!
And we can't forget about the absurdly evil words like:
"For here you are, and what was just a world is a star tonight": Well, I'm glad it's still a world, because we'd all burn up if it were a star.
But seriously, I'd say those songs are two of the best songs in the world, save for those weirdly absurd lyrics.
"How could she just suddenly, completely disappear into thin water?" - The Little Mermaid