I Am Cait — Page 7

Wow, really quite dense.

So, a man who had an accident or horrible cancer and lost his penis or testicles is now a woman?

Ask the Headbanned about that! It's one of his obsessions. That and abortion.

if you're gonna say something like that then back it up. what do you mean

jerseygirl2, you are talking about freak accidents and things beyond our control. Incidents like that are the exception to the definition of a man

What did u not understand what I said? According to gender, if a man dresses up in women's clothing, he is to be considered a women. Don't you think that is bs?

Society is the one that tells us women can wear makeup and heels and men can't. That's what the term gender is about

You are really missing the point. Clothing has NOTHING to do with gender. My friend is not trans, yet she shops in the men's department. She's a stone butch, but do NOT call her a man. She isn't. Caitlyn Jenner dressed as a man for decades, despite knowing that she was really female in her brain. I have big feet and often buy men's Chuck Taylors. I am very much a woman. It has to do with your own perception and having the respect for someone to believe them when they tell you their gender.

How a man's genitals are removed isn't the point, unless you are just making up the rules you expect everyone to adhere to as you go. You said having a penis and creating sperm equals a being a man. The bear has no penis or testicles, yet he is very large, muscular and physically masculine. He chose to remove those parts of himself. You're saying he is a woman?

Updated On: 8/14/15 at 07:09 PM

YOU are the one who keeps saying it is.

i go by the definition, so if he has a penis, he is still a man, and was always a man

Penis=man. That's a fact

His soul is a woman but he has a penis so he's a man. That's just the definition. There is no arguing that. When he gets a vagina then he will be a woman

Updated On: 8/14/15 at 07:11 PM

No one has any idea what you are talking about.

Yes I do. You just don't get it

It's weird how E! are supportive on the one hand (with I Am Cait) but all transphobic on the other with the coverage of Kendra and Hank's marital problems. Why they always gotta point out he had an affair with a "transgendered woman", instead of just a woman? Does the fact that she is transgendered make is somehow worse or somehow more icky? Does it somehow imply that Hank isn't altogether hetero? Is it a valid talking point? Should I send a strongly-worded tweet expressing my concerns?

Never read the comments! :)

"You clearly have no idea what I'm talking about."

Doesn't our inability to make sense of your backwards gibberish somewhat fall on you, though? I've disagreed with many people on here, but I understood what they were saying in the process.