Sir Andrew Lloyd Weber said it best, "I never really thought I'd see a man singing 'Memory' with dreaklocks." Hahaha Let the butchering begin...
That was pretty awful.
Thank you Randy! It was a "train wreck!"
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/27/05
Oh God, that was HILARIOUS.
He didn't know Cats was about cats!
Well, Hal Prince did think the show was about Queen Victoria when he heard the concept ALW....
Poor Jason. "Memory" of all songs... I'm embarrassed for him, I thought he was going to faint during the performance.
Sir Webber was dead on! and if brooke is decent tonight then castro is gone and I can rejoice! I cannot wait for david cook.
To me Syesha was boring. We've seen that before. You can see anyone on Broadway or regional theatre pull that off. Boring.
Castro put his spin on the song. If the song wasn't from Cats or well known, he could do quite well with it. He has a certain style and it worked for him.
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/27/05
I love how he had to take a breath like every other word.
I'm not sure which made me cringe more.
His performance or seeing hands waving in the air during memory...
He never changes how he sings. It's always soft and whiney. That doesn't work for Memory.
Oh, Brooke. Has that ever happened before?
She started over?? on national TV!!?? Shes gone.
They really can't get it right tonight.
Well it's weird she messed up, but it was very professional... I like when she makes a mistake she fixes it, like she did with "Let it Be." She is a real person and so likable. That's what makes her great.
She's done that twice now. But no, no one's ever done that.
I agree, yankee. I love her just because she's so genuine.
hahahaha stick to priest! Is that like the second or third time this season that has happened? I hate to say shes probably gone. She didnt sound absolutly terrible, definitly not as bad as jason.
She is so real and so genuine. I love her.
I love her though.
She really is a ray of sunshine.
That song is in a weird place for me too.
I'd buy her album for sure. And I can't say that about anyone else so far. Probably David Cook, too, actually.
She isn't the best vocalist. But she is so real and her voice expresses that.
Paula is soooooo dumb. Her comments were sooooo dumb. Dumber than usual.
The fact that Syesha is probably going to be around longer than Brooke makes me sad.
Videos