He did, when the camera went behind and above him. You could hear him mumbling his way through it. It was after that whole "Won't you think of meeeee..." When he came back in he didn't know where he was. Updated On: 4/22/08 at 08:49 PM
I didnt catch him either but Carly's doing pretty good
But that's not saying a lot, Simon. I do think she was singing it in too high a key.
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/27/05
Carly's performance was a mess. And she screwed up the lyrics three times.
I loved Carly. Great performance. Maybe a female Judas...hey Trokia??
she may have screwed up the lyrics but it was one one of the better ones tonight. David Cook will be incredible as always though.
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/27/05
I can't stand David Cook or the song he is singing (unless it is sung by an amazing male singer, which Cook is not), so I'm thinking my vote's going to go to Syesha.
Boy they are really f-ing up the lyrics tonight.
"Think of me, whembumblsaymmmbleehhhhmmm, when we say goodbye"
he didnt screw up the arrangement!!!! I LOVE HIM!!!
Another lyric ****-up.
Jesus Christ, he sounds like Gerard Butler.
Well, they're singing ALW songs.. so thats one strike against them.
Broadway Star Joined: 3/20/08
I was expecting a rock arrangement of "Music of the Night". This version is putting me to sleep.
What's the scarf?
I was just thinking he sounded like Gerard Butler, particularly on the "gehhhrish light of day." People, it's GAHrish.
Updated On: 4/22/08 at 08:58 PM
"Falling.... floating...."
About how I am loving Cook right now... His high note was marvelous and the rest of it is perfectly subtle... But I did not like his pronunciation of "garish." Hahaha Oh the ending ruined it...
This is one of my favorite songs and he is totally putting me to sleep.
WTF was that last note!?
The ending was...uh...interesting?
haah yeah. I was like oh the ending is NIIIIIIC_WTF!
That sucked...what is going on with these judges?
"The ending was...uh...interesting?"
Hehe....that's one way to describe it!
"Music of the NAHHHHHHHHHHGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGT!"
He said "garish" weird and "face" sounded like "fate."
Let's never do this again, American Idol. Please.
Videos