Saw the matinee today, having seen the evening performance last Saturday. The show appears to be frozen now, with the possible exception that the quiet bit between Patrick and Jean is a touch improved on pacing. Seems like there were a bunch more supporters at today's show; the audience is still mostly quiet during the bulk of Act II, but there were lots more laughs at various lines in both acts today, as well as a more raucous curtain call. I think folks are starting to catch on to what the show is and isn't.
IMHO, Act II is designed to be tonally different from Act I. It seems logical to me that the creative team would intend that the sort of roller-coaster ride you're taking in Act I, culminating with the big-thrill drop at the end, should give way to a much more grim and disturbing tone as Patrick's madness is proving much more unnerving and unpleasant by now. I actually liked Act II more today than I did the first time.
Call it this generation's Rocky Horror if you want to, the only relationship this show has to Ghost is that both shows were imports. While Ghost was essentially the movie with a bunch of ballads stuffed into it (in some cases, back-to-back), AP acts as a self-contained interpretation of the basic theme with only a few nods to the movie.
So what makes a great musical? It's purely subjective. All I know is that this show is almost an anti-musical, if one was to assign quality based on sentiment and sappiness. This show is devoid of both, and I think a significant chunk of the audience feels like they were overdue for something like this show. God, I know I was; I appreciated it even more this second viewing.
One final arbitrary addendum: I'm slowly starting to realize that nothing polarizes a population like irony. Some people (like myself) are perfectly happy to ingest and expel stuff when it's wrapped in a blanket of irony; others simply abhor it, lamenting (perhaps understandably) that people don't seem to just SAY what they're thinking anymore. I would say the book, movie, and now this show are steeped in irony - which may or may not be how you like your musical theatre. Caveat emptor.
Updated On: 4/16/16 at 10:29 PM