Musicaldudepeter said: "I always associated Mrs Lovett with the great character actress leading lady types like a Mary Testa, Judy Kaye, Christine Ebersole--women who always appeared 50+ even when they were 25... and Angela Lansbury, Patti LuPone, Christine Baranski, Julia McKenzie, Emma Thompson all seem to fit this mould. Ever since Bonham Carter in the movie, it's become the property of younger, prettier leading lady performers like Ashford and now Foster."
I get that Sutton Foster reads as younger, she literally starred in a TV show with that premise, but she's going to turn 49 a month into doing the role.
For me, casting Angela Lansbury, who was perfect as Mrs. Lovett, at least in retrospect, seems like a bigger example of casting against type. The nice old lady from Murder She Wrote is turning her customers into cannibals?