I saw it again yesterday and, now having seen all three, Paul-Jordan Jansen is by and far the winner of the three. Groban was good, Christopher was great. Jansen is downright TERRIFYING. When he got into Sweeney's attack mode Turpin evades him the first time, I felt genuine fear - which is a testament to him because when you can catch a repeat patron off guard with your performance, you've done a highly commendable job.
I met with some friends in the cast after and, while I heard nothing of Joe Locke, I heard that Tveit is apparently shaping up to be very surprising. I didn't hear anything about Sutton either, but I don't know what her rehearsal schedule is like in tandem with Once Upon A Mattress.
The only alternate I have not seen is DeLaney Westfall and I've heard great things. I love Jeanna De Waal's portrayal and, for some weird reason, she reminds me of Jessie Mueller.
Check out my eBay page for sales on Playbills!!
www.ebay.com/usr/missvirginiahamm