Ok, I'm on my way back from the show. Forgive any typos, as I'm typing this on my phone. I'll post a more detailed report later, but for now I'll say these things:
Overall, I really enjoyed it. It's not perfect, nor is it groundbreaking, but it has a lot of charm and beauty and heart.
They've captured the movie well in a number of ways:
-the emphasis on the community and the voice of individual strangers. The small ensemble acts as the narrator for the show, but all exist as their own characters.
-The nature of Amelie's struggle between interaction and solitude. As well as her imaginative and often silly mind.
-The theme of details and likes/dislikes, and how they affect everyone's identity
The book is not perfect. It tries to remain very faithful to the movie, almost to a fault. Some of the things that worked well on screen didn't translate perfectly onto the stage. But even these issues were not horrible. They clearly understood the themes of the movie, and made us care about Amelie and her relationship with Nino.
The score is pretty, and often moving. It's reminiscent of modern musicals by composers like Tom Kitt and Brian Loudermilk. One issue is that most of the songs sound the same. But what it lacks in variety, it makes up for in its effective lyrics. The songs are well-utilized to develop character and enhance the emotion of the story, which is ultimately what songs in a musical should do.
The cast is excellent. They all have beautiful stand-out moments, and many play multiple characters very effectively.
Design elements are well done. The set was pretty and the projections, thanks goodness, were tasteful and well-integrated.