I just came home. I rushed it this morning. Sadly, the Mezz was about a third full- I was able to move to the center of the second row at intermission.
It was my first time seeing a production of Follies, and it's the last main Sondheim score I never really got into until recently.
I have to say, I was blown away by the production. The weak link in a very, very strong chain was, for me, Ron Raines (when Ben and Buddy reunite, Ron accidentally said "Danny!" but then quickly covered it up). Of the four principle roles, he was the least fleshed-out for me- and his final breakdown was sort of anticlimactic.
However, I thought the other three were all outstanding and award-worthy. Bernadette sounds and looks gorgeous- her Sally was pitiable, but I never found her "pathetic". Deluded? More than likely manic depressive? Naive? Absolutely.
Danny Burstein was incredible. He made "The Right Girl" work incredibly, and his "God-Why-Don't-You-Love-Me Blues" was both comedic and laced with the sadness of understanding. His exit following that number, hat in hands, was almost heartbreaking- but what actually was heartbreaking was his leaving with Sally. He goes to put his arm around her- and then doesn't. Jeez.
Jan Maxwell really shines in Act Two. I believe they've changed a deal "Lucy and Jessie" since DC (based on what I've seen around). The choreography is more Phyllis-centric and less about athletic chorus boys. She more or less poses and shows off her legs most of the time, which I think is fine and works, although I still long for her to do "Ah, But Underneath". But she sells what she's got beautifully. Her "Could I Leave You?" is outstanding, a breakdown of bitterness but also a show of strength.
The ensemble women are all great. "Who's That Woman?" stopped the show, as did Jayne Houdyshell's "Broadway Baby". Houdyshell really is a pleasure to watch- seeing her delight at performing once again revives what has become a classic, done-to-death song. "One More Kiss" was beautiful, but what really made it for me was Rosalind Elias taking the stage. Someone said she did it with trepidation or hesitance. I didn't feel that. Yes, there was a hesitance. But I felt that it was the hesitance that a performer feels when they walk onto the bare stage of an empty theatre. They have material they can do- a monologue, a song. There are memories- especially in Heidi's case. But there's no one there. Is there? The opportunity to do something is there, but it's...it's an odd feeling to jump into it. That's what I got from her slowly moving downstage to start her song.
Elaine Paige was fine. I found her self-indulgent in the way I find Patti LuPone to be. Her "I'm Still Here" is good, until she starts shouting at the end, which was rather inexplicable.
I thought the design elements were all beautiful. The costumes, including Sally's much-discussed dress, were all great. I really loved the Loveland bed of roses. The lighting I found to be exemplary.
The set is, I think, fine. It's a theatre interior. It does what it needs to do and goes no further, and conceals no tricks nor does it try to be anything but a realistic depiction.
The feel of the theatre is amazing. I believe someone complained upon seeing the drapery that it looked like the inside of a tent- I had no such feeling of it in the theatre. It honestly looks, aside from the seats and various other things they could not cover, like a crumbling theatre. Funnily enough, a row of house lights at the back of the mezz were on the fritz, flickering on and off before the show. Hardly planned but also appropriate.
As a whole, I came out of the show moved and pensive, and also exhilarated. The rest of the audience, it seemed, was in the same boat- all discussing performances and lyrics as they walked out.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."