RippedMan said: "Billy Elliot won the Tony and made a profit. I didn't under perform."
I'm not calling it a "flop" by any means, but the producers were expecting a better financial performance/longer run on Broadway than it actually had. It ran 11 years in London. The infrastructure of training and constantly replacing the dancers was tough. It lost the Tony for Best Score. It was never a cultural phenomenon here in the way that it was in the UK. On the flip side, I'm sure things like HAMILTON will run longer on Broadway than in the UK. MATILDA was a similar situation in NYC, though it ran slightly longer, but it had dismal financial returns post-recoupment.
Hard to compare GROUNDHOG DAY London vs Broadway, because in London it was a limited engagement at a nonprofit theatre.