Went and saw this last night, had really high hopes based on this board, so I left feeling a bit disappointed. This will do just fine on Broadway, but it isn't a revelation, and outside of Tech it won't be winning (maybe even competing) for any Tony Awards.
I hate comparing the two because of the massively different tone, but it feels alot like Spongebob from last season. Amazing tech, a few endearing moments, and you leave feeling okay about the experience. If you hate kitsch you will DEFINITELY hate this. And it was easily the most vulgar thing I have seen since BOM, so the ads are true. And in 2018, I was a bit sad to see so many jokes about groping unwilling participants.
PROS:
The Set steals the show here. Everything about it is gold, and the lighting design is a perfect compliment. The way they do just about everything is magnificent, if anything Timbers' staging doesn't use the set as well as it could have.
Rob McClure is wonderful, and Kerry Butler is rock solid. The writers leave them with the worst arc (where the heck is the resolution?!), and they still manage to do a lot of nice things. They are genuine and quirky.
Sofia Anne Caruso is every bit as good as advertised. I was thrilled that a show finally cast a teenager as a teenager. It was believable and engaging. She does miss a few moments of nuance, but 95% of it is high quality stuff. The 30 year olds as teenagers trend on bway is getting a bit tired, so I applaud this choice and her work. I could easily see a Tony Nom for her.
Leslie Kritzer is hysterical: Especially in her early (and only) number. I wish they had given her more. She kind of gets left behind in the plot.
Jill Abramovitz and Danny Rutigliano are also very funny and add a great deal to the ensemble: I loved every bit role these two played. They were very funny, especially in the "Day-Oh" scene.
CONS:
The neverending Music. People have commented before, but I don't think you can prepare for it. Act 1 is constant songs...and not in a good way. They make a joke about an early ballad, and then proceed to have Alex Brightman scream at us non-stop for an hour. At more than one point I looked at my date and rolled our eyes that a NEW song was starting. The book's entire function in Act 1 was to drive to the next song. And, unfortunately, the songs weren't that great. They had some fine numbers, but...nothing really awesome.
Alex Brightman is exhausting. I will admit that I hated him in SOR. I felt like he just ran around and screamed, and had hoped to never see him on stage again, so I was disappointed that he was doing this role. I had hopes, though, from folks who told me that Dewey was directed to be that way, and this role would be different and nuanced. It wasn't. He is incredibly annoying. He landed some jokes, but the whole role felt like a talented high schooler who flies through the nuance so that he can get to the sex jokes and say the f word. To his credit, most of the crude jokes land.
The opening number is a train wreck. It just makes no sense, it is done at Hyper speed and gives you NO insight into what the show is going to be about. "Its a show about death." No crap, but the exposition is glossed over at a nauseatingly spastic rate. It took me a few minutes to just settle in to the show after that number. It is a bit deceptive, but I think they should start with Caruso's ballad and move into a truncated version of a show about death.
IT IS TOO LONG. - My lord, when are people going to come around on the 100 min, no intermission train. This should could be twice as nice at about two hours. Add in the fact that we took a 23 minute intermission (I could watch a sitcom on Hulu during the break!), it came in around 2:45. OOOF.
UNNECESSARY REPRISES - This is the show of hearing songs we didnt like the first time over and over again. Poor Sofia gets reprise after reprise of stuff (which she mostly kills), but it isn't good stuff, so it gets boring after a bit. Alex gets reprises of many songs (his and Sofia's), and I just don't get why...
Overall - I'd give this show a solid B-. It feels like many of last season's mediocre shows(Mean Girls, Spongebob), so it'll fit right in on Bway.