Bette's Turban said: "Mister Matt said: "It doesn't help that this is a TERRIBLE time to bring a show into Chicago. The weather is traditionally awful (everybody gets sick during the annual Halloween cold snap) and the run ends before the tourists come in for the holidays. The nearby Christkindlmarket, which brings LOADS of people daily into the Loop doesn't open until the final two days of performances."
It also doesn't help that there is no Bette or the likes of her and it is a very old show ."
That last line says it all. When we left the theater last night I noticed many younger members of the audience were audibly mocking the show. If you've never seen Dolly! before, it's a creaky old mess of a show, really; the book just doesn't make sense. I had to explain to my husband what was going on in the Harmonia Gardens scenes and the courtroom scene, because if you've not seen it before, especially the way the end of the dance scene in Harmonia gardens is staged in this version, those scenes just make no sense at all. He had no idea what on earth Dolly was doing there, what Ernestina was doing, or why the police showed up. This show didn't really put those parts over, I agree.
But mostly, in a theater scene like Chicago, where you have great theater companies like Steppenwolf and the Goodman and the Red Orchid, plus Hamilton still packing them in two years running, this show, without a STAR! DIVA!, isn't going to excite audiences. And Betty Buckley isn't that kind of diva, at least not in this show; she can't overcome the material, she never transcends it. She's just too--quiet. She comes off as older than Horace, as well, which is an odd visual. I've not heard any buzz about it, other than the surprising rave review from the Tribune. And I'd also agree with those who say the Oriental Theater is too big for this production; that might have contributed to the disappointing, creaky feel of this production, the night I saw it (11/10). It's not a huge cast, but it's a huge stage and house. And the way they built out the stage left a great hole in the middle - the pit was in front of the build out - that, frankly, made me worry throughout the show. I was afraid someone was going to fall into it (although I'm sure that wasn't really a possibility; they must have put some cover over it, but still, it worried me from my seat).
Updated On: 11/11/18 at 12:28 PM