@Theater'sBestFriend - I'm assuming you're not a producer because I would not guess you'd be very good at it. If the unions said no, you would then have months and months to prepare for it. Maybe you book different stars in a different order that won't leave you with a weeklong gap if you know that gap is going to be fatal. Maybe you book a lesser star or an up and comer with at least some name recognition who would jump at the chance to headline a Broadway show even if it's only for a week. If 54 Below and every other nightclub across the country can figure out how to book a name star for a one week engagement, why can't After Midnight? You figure something out and you don't wait until a few weeks before the fact to realize you've got a problem you can't solve.
Many Broadway shows have had a "name star in the lead role" leave the production and the new "name star in the lead role" is not able to start for a week. They have an understudy cover it for 1 week. Maybe attendance is down that week but they don't have to shut the whole show down completely because of 1 person in a cast of dozens. It's July 4th week. Tourists will be pouring in to NYC for the holiday and the fireworks and unlike some of the folks in this thread, they don't have the ability to wait until the following week when a name star starts. They will have heard the show is good and will go anyway cause that's the week they are in New York, especially if the producers get a little creative with the pricing for that week and offer some great deals.
There are lots of different ways they could have handled this but apparently they have Theater'sBestFriend's creativity and apparently just couldn't figure it out.
Updated On: 6/15/14 at 11:59 PM