I finally saw this the following day because I was at the NYC theater with the technical problems. I have a LOT of thoughts, but for laziness' sake I won't go into exhaustive detail. I absolutely disagree with the need to force the show back into the 70's, but overall I still really enjoyed it; to me, after everything, seeing any version of Company is just sort of like seeing an old friend. And when enough time has gone by, I feel like I fall in love with it all over again. I had this goofy grin plastered on my face the entire time, even in the moments when I was moved to the inevitable Company-tears.
I thought everyone was really well-cast, though I was most disappointed with Patti. I felt like she just got up there and said the lines and sang the song without giving much thought to the depth and the importance of what she's saying to the show. If you fail at the Joanne-Bobby relationship, as far as I'm concerned, you fail at the show as a whole. You can still do everything really, really well, but you've missed a part THAT crucial. This may have just been a sound thing, but I thought that vocally, the group numbers sounded horrible. Everyone sounded fine on their own, but awful together. The group numbers were pretty meh, but I found something to love, rediscover, laugh at, or see differently in every single one of the couple scenes, and that was what really made the experience so enjoyable for me. I know that show so well that I could do it in my sleep -- so if you can surprise me, and give it something I hadn't really thought of, that's all I can ask for. Special mention to Colbert, JLT and Christina Hendricks on that.
NPH is someone I've always wanted to see as Bobby -- in fact, if the revival had run, he's who I would have picked to replace Raul. So it was kind of strange when, once he was actually about to play the part, I suddenly got sort of nervous and skeptical. I was worried that I would see NPH-doing-Bobby, and not this character I'm so much in love with. I don't think anyone will ever play the part, at least in my eyes, as beautifully and devastatingly as Raul did; I'm too in love with everything about that production to ever be fair, and I know that. But NPH definitely won me over, as I guess I knew he would all those years back when I wished for this. He sang it much better than I thought he would. I think he sounded best in Marry Me A Little. There were few surprises from him for me, but I still think he gave a lovely, charming, careful performance that reminded me why I fell in love with this character in the first place. My only big Bobby disappointment was in the staging: the final image was such a throwaway. Totally stale.
I thought Tick Tock was awful. If you're going to do it, you need to DO IT. I hated having the five (or whatever) dancers, and the choreography was really bland. Maybe that's just because I've seen the original and it's magnificent, but that was really disappointing. If you're going to include that number, make it count, give it some punch. This version was just like some kind of weird interlude.
The orchestrations were stunning, particularly in Another Hundred People, where they were pearl-clutchingly gorgeous.
Points to Lonny Price for making it clear that Bobby does indeed have a mirror above his bed. Because he so would.
It was a much more cheery, straightforward, literal production than the Company I met five and a half years ago. But I liked that it was so different. Throughout the whole thing, I couldn't wait to get to the next scene because I was so curious and excited to see how they were going to do it. I had to choose between seeing this and going to Shakespeare in the Park, and it was a tough decision but I think it was definitely the right call. It made me miss that magnificent year, but, my God, I saw Company on a movie screen. Bittersweetness and all, I had to be there for that.
A work of art is an invitation to love.
Updated On: 6/19/11 at 12:12 PM