KingOfTheMine said: "Saw this last night and thought it was verygood, if a bit uneven. I've seen a lot of talk about how Lenk's acting makes up for her weak singing, but I thought her performance was emotionally flat. Bobbie is sort of a bystander for most of the piece, but she has two moments to really knock it out of the park and give her perspective with Marry Me a Little and Being Alive. For me, Lenk just didn't portray the heights of emotion required by those songs and seemed unsure of herself. I've been trying to figure out what other people were picking up on that I missed. I was in the front mezz, and the Jacobs isn't that large. Still, maybe her acting choices are just too subtle to be appreciated from the mezz? Even so, I thought she improved in Act II, and I bet she gets better throughout the preview period.
This supporting cast is an embarrassment of riches. Everyone is doing what they do best. Some highlights: Jennifer Simard and Chris Sieber have some of the best comic timing in the business, and the audience ate up their scene. Matt Doyle delivered a solid Getting Married Today,even though the rapturous response is really because of Elliott's staging. The highlight wasgettingto hear Patti LuPone sing The Ladies Who Lunch live, which was everything I wanted it to be and worth the price of admission.
The physical production is good, even if Elliott is relying on her usual bag of tricks. I don't think it's good enough to distract from the flaws inherent in the piece. However, there's no denying that this is an entertaining production. I couldn't believe that the run time had been nearly three hours once it was over because I was so engaged. What the piece really needs to get to the next level is a stronger performance at the center to pull everything together. It will go from very good to great once Lenk has some time to flesh out her performance."
Great review. I agree with pretty much all of this except about Lenk's acting, which I found to be very good, but I was very close to the stage, so that might have something to do with it.