RippedMan said: "I don't see this show being a contender for anything - save for Cassie Levy who I think is a star. I'm curious to see the stage/design. I didn't see much in the pics, but I LOVE design and so curious what they do with this. This is the biggest Disney property in awhile, and I'm so surprised they went with such a dark, moody director. Wonder if Casey was ever asked?
"
See, after dong research on Grandage, I was thrilled that's the direction they went with. Obviously I'm not sure what Timbers' vision might have been, but I was always worried about how "up and Disney" that the Disney authorities would want this. Disney has alway been known for being completely honest and earnest with how they tell stories, and Casey would not have done that at all, Aladdin being proof. If they were gonna go "tourist trap" and/or "all musical comedy" direction, then yeah hire Casey...I like him, but honesty/earnestness isn't his strong suit. So I really do think Grandage is a pretty damn good choice. And I always envisioned this being more abstract/dark/moody myself, so obviously some bias is there, but that kind of vision will add an extra element/layer to this and keep it from being nothing but a comedy and "cutesy Disney".
"Maybe it'll be different when they're in costume but right now... eh? Not that casting people who look exactly like the animated cartoons should be the biggest priority but I feel like they barely tried. If you squint really hard and stand across the room, John Riddle bears the closest resemblance to his character. And Caissie's blond. It is going to make money anyway but I hope they've really worked on the story and extra songs because I don't think just seeing this translated to the stage is going to make it interesting like Aladdin or even Beauty and the Beast. I almost wish they'd cast the standbys as the leads and really broken with the original movie so it wouldn't be so easy to invite comparisons. Or cast Betsy Wolfe."
Much agreed. The casting doesn't bother me nearly as much as everything else. It's cast well and I'm sure more interesting choices will come in the future. Now You say break with the mold, but yet you seem fine with Riddle? No shade I'm just curious since Riddle hardly breaks the mold. I think we all can agree Alladin is the biggest mold breaker here, the best part is that it makes perfect sense since Laplanders do/did have a decently large population of people who were very dark skinned.
As for stage translating? Yeah this isn't one you can just throw on stage and expect it to work, the DCA show proves it. I've always felt this can work on stage, but it needs work. A LOT if it. Even Aladdin could have worked but since that went complete "tourist trap" show, it doesn't, it's far from interesting, but that's me...