pmensky said: "Considering a new Broadway season will be starting up in the fall, Julie Benko may have a shiny new job lined up by the time Beanie departs. Benko has had a big platform to show her talent, and after seeing her performance, I wouldn’t be surprised if there were producers and directors who’d be interested in putting her in a new show."
These are all hypotheticals but at the moment if she had the opportunity to do Fanny full-time, she'd be foolish not to. "Finish what she started." Unless Bart Sher wants to give her Guinevere, or there was a REALLY good lead role in a brand-new musical with a Broadway contract.
She's not going to be well-served by leaving to originate a role equivalent to Whitney Bashor in MJ or Person 7 in Come From Away. Especially if the narrative was "she was so good as Fanny that it made the producers want to offer Beanie an early exit."
One other reason to hire her full time for Fanny: the producers know exactly what they're getting. There's no question of her stamina or if something she did in an audition was a fluke. And following the casting risk that was Beanie with the "safe" in-house choice could be a good thing.
Updated On: 6/15/22 at 07:24 PM